For in-house lawyers, being put on the spot is often part of the job. Whether it's an unexpected question from a senior stakeholder, pressure to provide an immediate legal view or having to respond without all the facts, knowing how to handle these situations confidently can be challenging.
But responding effectively doesn't always mean having an immediate answer. It's about creating space to think, managing expectations and knowing how to communicate what you can confidently advise on, while recognising when something needs further consideration.
We asked members of our in-house legal community to share their experiences and practical advice on handling pressure in meetings and responding with confidence.
Key takeaways
- Don't feel pressured to fill the silence: Taking a moment to think before responding can demonstrate composure and help you formulate a more considered answer.
- Be comfortable saying you don't know: Acknowledging when you need to check something or seek further advice is better than giving a rushed or speculative answer.
- Give an initial view where appropriate: You can remain helpful without overcommitting by explaining your initial thoughts and being clear about what still needs checking.
- Get context before the meeting: Ask for agendas, background information and anticipated questions in advance to help avoid being caught off guard.
- Understand the question behind the question: Take time to clarify what stakeholders actually need to know, what they're trying to achieve and what pressures they may be facing.
- Focus on the practical answer: Legal advice isn't just about knowing the law; it's about applying it in the context of the organisation and helping the business make informed decisions.
Jonathan Friend - UK & EMEA Lead Senior Privacy Counsel at Wise
When you're under pressure from a senior stakeholder, wanting an immediate answer and you're not ready to give one, the instinct is often to say something. If you don't, they might think you don't know or aren't engaged.
But, you need mental space to think, and you may have more context and facts than they do, which is why they are asking you the question. Sometimes the question they're asking isn't even the legal question that matters.
A good way to start is to repeat the question back. "So you're asking me... what you actually need to know is..."
This does several things. You're buying thinking time whilst organising your thoughts as you're saying it. You're demonstrating to them that you’re getting clarity on what they're actually asking and what they really need to know. You're only answering the parts you're confident in answering right now.
That way people get the information they need without feeling you're fudging it, and you've shown you're answering their question directly.
The other thing is understanding what's actually driving them. Someone might be pushing for your response because of their own pressures, such as scrutiny in their role, which has nothing to do with you. You need mental space to do your own thinking. There may be other facts you don't have. It's important to set out those gaps.
Sometimes you should be responding to a different question altogether – one that's more useful for what they want to know. Being able to frame that in the meeting is powerful, if you have the context of what's actually a legal risk.
Gethin Bennett - Assistant Legal Counsel, The Royal Mint
Create that well-needed space before you respond
I think many / most of us often feel the need to show our worth by contributing something, but I always think there’s strength in knowing you don’t actually have to fill the silence.
After all, a short pause can signal composure and, more crucially, gives you a moment to think (/panic!!!). If needed, I find it helps to say it plainly: “Let me take a moment on that / Let me take that away and come back to you.”
Use a credible holding line rather than guessing
Similarly, there’s also real strength in saying “I don’t know yet, but I know where to look / who to ask” – especially for us in-house lawyers who have to deal with such an eclectic in-tray every day. Doing it that way, in my experience, is more reassuring than a rushed, half-formed answer – and, of course, it protects your credibility.
Offer direction, not definitives
Easier said than done I know but, under pressure, aim to steer rather than to conclude. I tend to find that a simple structure works well: “My initial view is X, subject to checking Y.” In other words, you stay helpful without over committing. The same can apply to e-mails/ other comms methods too, of course, not just in high-pressured meetings.
Push back on (is it really?) urgency
Ah, the infamous “this is urgent” from stakeholders! Not every question needs an instant (legal) answer. If something feels rushed, say so: “I’m not comfortable giving a final position without checking that properly.” Good stakeholders respect that in my experience – they’d rather you take it away and do some digging, than blagging a botched answer on-the-spot.
Reduce pressure before you walk in
Finally, this is one of the most important (if not the most important, actually) tactic to battle pressure in my world. I always try to ask for context, pre-empted questions, papers or an agenda in advance of the meeting. We’ve all had those invites for an hour-long “Catch-up” or “Quick question”! It’s a simple habit to ask for that direly needed background beforehand, but can turn surprise questions into prepared conversations.
Sam McGinty – Director of Legal Services – University of Nottingham
It starts before the meeting and establishing the scope and nature of your role as a lawyer. It’s not our job to know all of the laws – where we add value, it’s because we have the skills to go and find the answers and place them into the context of the organisation’s mission and goals.
While you can’t always say ‘I’ll take that away’, if pushed you can sometimes give an answer in the meeting which you think is right and then immediately check and then follow up in writing.
While we need to get the law right, the longer you are in an organisation, the more you can understand what the business or pragmatic answer to a legal question is – most clients don’t want to hear what law or case led to the position, they just want the position.
Camilla Beevor – In-house Lawyer at Historic Royal Palaces
Firstly I think it’s important to acknowledge that lawyers generally are smart and thoughtful, and in-house lawyers tend also to have a very broad knowledge base and a lot of commercial sense. Therefore, if you don’t have the answer to something off the top of your head, it’s probably because the matter needs further consideration.
Once I came to terms with this, I found I was able to be more confident in meetings where my colleagues expected immediate answers – I gave them my initial thoughts where I could, and I explained I would consider the matter further and get back to them with some more formal advice. It’s rare that anyone has been disappointed with this approach and I think that’s partly due to having a calm and confident manner, even when you’re saying that you need more time, or to get some external support.